I watched The Stand the other night. The long ass TV miniseries based off Stephen King's book. And boy, I wasn't a fan. Production values may have had something to do with it, but I think mostly it's me realizing that Stephen King is really into Good vs. Evil. This is the (almost) end of The Stand. The crazy crowd with semi-automatics are the bad guys, and the people they're about to "crucify" are the good guys. You probably didn't really need for me to explain that, though. It reminds me of Jesus Christ Superstar... except totally un-ironic and, seemingly, un-self-aware. As you can see the crazy crowd is led literally by a demonic figure (played by Jamey Sheridan! He made a great lieutenant on Criminal Intent)...
Did you catch the giant hand? The giant Hand of God? I laughed when I saw that, but apparently it's in the book as well.
What's funny is I was about to write about how cool the on-going Vegas-chill music in the background is, and then I realized I was still listening to the Mulholland Drive soundtrack underneath the youtube video. So, maybe if you watch The Stand while listening to Mulholland Drive's luscious
"Go Get Some," some of the didactic effect is muffled.
I didn't realize how really
into this sort of thing King is until I read Under the Dome. And at the time I read it, I was like, "where is the Stephen King I love?" But I now think that there are two Stephen Kings, and I only love one. That's the Stephen King of The Shining and Pet Sematary and Carrie and Night Shift and even Salem's Lot (although this one is kind of a bridge between the two "Kings"). The temptation is to say, oh, I liked him better younger, before he cleaned up, before the car crash, but no - The Stand was written around the same time as all the stuff I just mentioned. The Shining and Pet Sematary, my favorites, are both straight-up horror stories about people faced with incredibly taxing - but "real," and personal - situations (alcoholism and cabin fever/ death of a child), are basically handed this Opportunity by scary scariness, take the Opportunity, make a royal mess of everything, hurt others, and hurt themselves. The end. Carrie isn't too far from this theme either. Another example I like that isn't so popular is Riding the Bullet (death of a parent). Every time I watch this movie, late nights on USA, I get a little more out of it and what it has to say about death and our relationship with our parents. But another impossible situation and dark choice lies therein. Another short story that got turned into a movie, Apt Pupil, is another great example of this. You don't get a lot of anagnorisis in this one, and you're left wondering whose downfall you're really watching - the privileged teenager learning to kill (because what's his taxing situation?) or the former Nazi hiding in the suburbs.
Then there's "Last Stand" Stephen King. After The Stand, "Last Stand" Stephen King reappears in It (which is up there with the worst endings ever seen), Desperation (wow, this is a Christian story), and Under The Dome (we all know my opinions on that one). There may be others, but those are the ones I can really claim to know. The defining characteristic of "Last Stand" Stephen King is the use of ensemble casts, the "ragtag team forced to work together to defeat the forces of darkness" thing. And ensemble casts do make it hard to focus on one character's descent into the dark, but there's a lot of sloppy characterization that goes into the creation of these ensemble casts - which is why you can so easily parse these books for King's politics and, uh, religious preferences. There is no mystery in Under The Dome about who's Good and who's Evil because it is all so obviously coded: e.g., dogs (included in the
Dramatis Personae!) only belong to good people. "Last Stand" Stephen King also makes use of taxing situations, though they tend to be cosmic, or at least very physical and interactive rather than emotional and introspective. You get people literally trapped in prison cells, literally being near-annihilated by an apocalyptic flu, literally trapped under a literal freakin' dome.
Probably most importantly, "Last Stand" Stephen King is also into dark choices and the possibility of seduction by evil, but the good guys don't get seduced. These heroes don't falter. Maybe they've made some minute wrong decision earlier in life and have since learned the righteous path, or maybe they just needed the guiding hand of a saintly child (Desperation, all the way). Some people do fall into the dark trap, but these people are minor characters who meet terrible ends 2/3 of the way through. They're not who our sympathies are supposed to lie with, so when we watch Nadine jump from the evil Randall Flagg's balcony and go splat on the concrete, it's a distanced "well that's what you get for siding with Evil" sort of effect instead of the sadder, more frustrated reaction you have to watching Jack Torrance chase his family around or watching Louis Creed bring his wife back from the dead even after he went through all that holy shit did you learn nothing Louis why why why. No. In "Last Stand" Stephen King, you don't watch downfalls, and you certainly don't fall down with them. You watch comeuppances from a safe distance. Most of the heroes, in fact, escape unscathed.
And of course, there is the stuff in between. Salem's Lot sets up a "Last Stand"-ish situation - humans against vampires - but aside from the vampires being predators, there's nothing very moralistic about the division, and the heroes are really whittled down by the end, and oh yeah, Father Callahan and his disastrous moment of doubt when faced with the head vampire. Easily my favorite part. Cujo actually doesn't have much of a dark choice or a downfall, because all that happens in the beginning of the story - to the poor St. Bernard Cujo, who really just gets infected with rabies. Cujo's my kind of Stephen King, though it's told by the victims instead of the maniac. Some people dislike Storm of the Century, but what I like about SotC is that even though the "moral choice" is clear - don't sacrifice your kids to people who might be demons - the little town doesn't make the right decision, and the hero who opposes them is severely punished, the end. There are moralistic implications, but it is balls to the wall as a horror story. Because part of why I don't like "Last Stand" Stephen King stories is that they fail for me as a piece of horror. They're more like action parables, and although there are a few token sacrifices, the bulk of the Good ensemble cast will probably survive. There is no danger in these stories. There's no unknown.
Jesus Christ, I didn't actually mean to write so much about Stephen King. Clearly King has really influenced me in my understanding of what makes a horror story through both positive and negative examples. What I really meant to write was something about why "Last Stands" between Good and Evil are so appealing, and what emotional button gets pushed by writing and reading this sort of narrative. Note that I don't know the answer to that, btw. And fuck it, it's 1 a.m. and this is what I'm going with. Enjoy The Hand of God, y'all.