intertribal: (Default)
intertribal ([personal profile] intertribal) wrote2007-05-05 10:27 pm

is YOUR roommate in love with her professor?

inspired by the facebook group kim joined earlier this year, "Help!  My Roommate is in Love with Her Professor!" and my own need to distinguish various girl student - male teacher relationships, to avoid being mistaken for the wrong type of coed. 

This is kind of an unusual quiz.  It operates by checks.  It's separated into categories.  Check every statement in each category that coincides, then count up the checks.  Whichever category has the most checks is your winner.

Category A
_  She says he's confident, but he's full of himself, and doesn't always know what he's talking about.
_  She keeps a list of mistakes he's made and puts it on the internet.
_  She likes to hog discussion time and talks down to other students.
_  She's very concerned about advancing in her field.
_  She likes getting into fights with him.
_  She might sleep with him just because she wants a challenge.
_  She forms opinions quickly and has no doubt that she's right.
_  She believes intelligence and correctness is the most important trait of a professor.

Category H
_  She says he's a moron. 
_  She never goes to office hours.
_  If he asked her to get drinks, she would attack him with pepper spray, claw his eyes out, make sure he's fired, and have him arrested.
_  She doesn't respond to his questions in class.
_  She doesn't understand how he got hired.
_  She didn't change her mind about anything even though he tried to convince her otherwise.
_  She writes bad reviews of him.
_  She does the readings, but throws everything away at the end of the year.

Category O
_  She says he's a good lecturer.
_  She does everything she has to do, but no more than that.
_  She took his class because her friends were taking it.
_  She skims the readings.
_  She only complains about class when there's a lot of homework.
_  She's never googled him. 
_  She's talked while he's lecturing.
_  She rarely brings him up, and certainly not during semester breaks.

Category V
_  She says he's hot.
_  She always wears low-cut shirts to class.
_  She giggles and wiggles a lot when she sees him.
_  She doesn't get her work done.
_  She's not very interested in the subject.
_  She's like this with all her male professors.
_  She really wants As, but she's not all that smart.
_  Friendly, nice professors are her favorite.

Category T
_  She says he's a genius.
_  She laughs very loudly at his jokes.
_  She rattles on and on after class about points he made, on every argument, straight from her exhaustive notes.
_  She thinks his wife and children are really cute and perfect.
_  She buys him Christmas presents.
_  She has a life outside of him.
_  She's considering this major just because he's such an awesome professor.
_  She often refers to him in a parental way.

Category N
_  She says he's a genius, hot, and a good lecturer.  And doesn't know why he's not tenured yet.
_  She knows where he lives.
_  She doesn't like to remember that he's married.
_  She constantly does all her work and her grades drop in other classes because of her attention to his class.
_  She dedicates Tegan & Sara songs to him.
_  She wants to know his life story.
_  She's jealous of other students when they get too close to him.
_  She has a list of little quotes of his that appear meaningless to most people.


ARCHANGEL (SATAN).  Your roommate's not in love with her professor - she thinks she's smarter than him.  Of course, she thinks she's smarter than everyone.  She seeks to rise in the ranks and possibly knock him off the top.  She will have succeeded when she publishes that controversial book that disproves everything he's been saying for the past ten years.  However, she doesn't actually think he's as dumb as she may say - she knows he's formidable - and does not dislike him as a person.

HERETIC.   Congratulations, your roommate is not in love with her professor.  She hates him, in fact.  The thought of him repulses her, and given the chance she would like to strike him down - but hell, he's not really worth the effort of a big sabotage attempt.  She won't be discussing him any further and will forget about him soon enough, except maybe to tell friends to steer clear of him. 

ON THE PEWS.  Your roommate is not in love with her professor.  She's indifferent and treats him like she would any other professor.  He may make some small minimal impact, and she might save a couple of the readings, and certainly boast about her grades, but no more than that.  She won't try to befriend him or send him emails, and doesn't plan on seeing him again, because he's not very important to her.

VIRGIN SLUT.  Unfortunately, your roommate is a ho.  Your roommate is not in love with her professor, but she's in lust with him, and hopes that the feeling is reciprocated - it's her only chance at getting straight As.  She chooses classes based on professors she predicts will be likely to be nice to her or at least want to bone her, expects to get good grades in return, and calls this networking.  She doesn't actually give a shit about him, though, so after the final grades are posted, he's dead to her. 

THEOLOGIAN.  There is love, but it's strictly platonic, as well as harmless and unlikely to cause mental duress.  She regards him as a father figure.  She will get starry-eyed when she hears the man speak forevermore, probably dedicate her thesis to him, and create a facebook group in his honor.  In return, she will get glowing recommendations.  She will also, however, have boyfriends, a regular life, and simply tell her children about good old Professor So-and-So and what he taught her about the aboriginal tribes of Papua New Guinea. 

NUN.  Yes, your roommate is in love with her professor.  Completely and utterly.  It will probably fuck her up for at least a while.  While the attraction is sexual, your roommate is not a ho and will probably never sleep with the professor, because she would not want to risk him being censured.  She cares about him as a person, admires him greatly, feels sharp emotional pangs around him, probably thinks about him many times throughout the day, and lives not for the good grades on her papers but the comments in the margins.
(deleted comment)

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-06 07:05 am (UTC)(link)
Well, that's what I would guess based on the fact that you rarely talk about any of them.

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-07 07:58 am (UTC)(link)
All my Tegan & Sara is for Josie. Can I substitute other songs? I mean, I have songs, I think that counts...

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-07 08:05 am (UTC)(link)
some of these sort of fit, sort of don't. i don't worship him or think he's superhuman, though i do think he doesn't give himself nearly enugh credit, and...oh yeah, i'm fucked up in school right now, so the only class i ever get anything done for is the one he cares about most, always, although it's also the one i'm most interested in, always, but i'm definitely not a good student. anyway. numbers approximate:

A: 0
H: 1
O: 1
V: 3
T: 5
N: 7

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-07 08:05 am (UTC)(link)
*enough

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-07 04:12 pm (UTC)(link)
Well, of course we don't worship them or think they're superhuman.... it's an exaggeration. I figured you would get this result, though.

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-08 10:55 am (UTC)(link)
i didn't say earlier, but i'm kind of flattered that you would think I'd be in the same category. might be evidence of my insanity but i am

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 02:58 am (UTC)(link)
wtf? flattered to be in the same category as me?

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 03:45 am (UTC)(link)
yeah, of course...

although it's a rather odd subject to say so about, perhaps.

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 03:52 am (UTC)(link)
um, that's a little weird, not gonna lie...

and hey, you're the one who's been to your prof's house... I just... you know... read it when I was supposed to be taking his tenure material to the provost's office... *bad me*

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:19 am (UTC)(link)
i could try to explain, but i'd probably sound ridiculous...

well, i imagine it'd be a lot weirder for a Barnard prof to hold class at his house...yeah.

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:22 am (UTC)(link)
I think it's been known to happen with the older professors... but not poli sci professors. And I can't imagine him ever holding class at his house.

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:25 am (UTC)(link)
In any case, that doesn't explain why you feel flattered to be in the same category as me with regards to this professor obsession thing. I mmean, you are CLEARLY just as obsessed as me, I mean, I think.

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:29 am (UTC)(link)
I cry when I try to resolve to stop contacting/emailing him "for non-work purposes." heh. (i've done that twice)

1) you're cool. i like being in categories with you. haha.
2) you seem very...protective and noble, not petty at all, etc., so that you would consider my feeling to be in the same category is flattering

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:32 am (UTC)(link)
Dude, I CAN'T EVEN CONTACT HIM EVER UNTIL SPRING 2008 BECAUSE HE'S ON LEAVE WHICH MEANS HE DOESN'T REPLY TO EMAIL AND PROBABLY DOESN'T HAVE A COMPUTER BECAUSE HE'S IN GOD KNOWS WHERE IN CENTRAL ASIA.

Aw, thanks. I am petty though. Sort of. I mean, with potential ho's, I am petty.

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:41 am (UTC)(link)
The point was more that I am ridiculous for crying at so small a thing, not that my situation is hard...

But I'm sorry. I didn't know he was on leave, too (in addition to you not being there for summer, etc.).

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:43 am (UTC)(link)
No, I know you weren't trying to say your situation is hard. It was more me expressing my shared frustration with a similar situation.

It's actually good that he's on leave. It gives me license to study abroad without feeling like, "if I didn't go to australia, I could see him". Because I wouldn't. And in any case, what am I going to write him about in the summer? Exactly.

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-08 11:14 am (UTC)(link)
Also, just for kicks, I checked the following:

She doesn't respond to his questions in class.

Either "She skims the readings" or "She's talked while he's lecturing," (first, for one of his classes and not the other, second, once or twice, like when Tara wrote, "I AM GOING TO KILL STEVE" on her notebook. or "FUCK STEVE." yeah, there are issues. he probably asked about the talking--class is very informal...and it might not have been him talking at the time--all conference classes)

She says he's hot. She doesn't get her work done. Friendly, nice professors are her favorite.

She says he's a genius. She laughs very loudly at his jokes (my laugh is annoying...). She thinks his wife and non-existent children are really cute and perfect. She buys him Christmas presents (not really, but I made him a cd, for which I will forever drown in embarrassment). Me? Have a life? She often refers to him in a parental way (I don't really know).

N: everything except doing work.

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 03:16 am (UTC)(link)
Me...
A: She's very concerned about advancing in her field; She believes intelligence and correctness *are the most important *traits of a professor.

O: She says he's a good lecturer.

V: She says he's hot.

T: She says he's a genius; She laughs very loudly at his jokes.

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 03:47 am (UTC)(link)
yeah, i figured those were the only 2 in A that would fit.

friendly, nice profs can be my favorite and i can also think intelligence and 'correctness' are important. but i don't know if i'd go so far as to say they're the most impt. not that being friendly is, either. i'd probably come up with something different, where both figure in somewhere in the rank order...

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 03:51 am (UTC)(link)
correctness actually means "we agree on things", for me. Like, that Professor Cooley also hates Samuel Huntington and believes the whole thing about Islam being incompatible with democracy is bullshit...

I agree that friendliness is a bonus. Although I would say "respectful" is more important to me.

[identity profile] royinpink.livejournal.com 2007-05-09 04:21 am (UTC)(link)
nice. (about the correctness) Well, if that's the case, then steve and i certainly agree about most things. there was one thing i disagreed about and stewed over for a week before realizing that he was right. sigh.

for profs in general, yeah, respect is more important.

[identity profile] intertribal.livejournal.com 2007-05-07 04:16 pm (UTC)(link)
My results:

A: 2
H: 0
O: 1
V: 1
T: 2
N: 8

of course, I made the quiz.